Deliciously Authentic Brick Oven Pizza

Old World Pizza | Broken Arrow

Experience the Timeless Taste of Old World Pizza, Made with Love, Tradition, and the Best Ingredients!

Broken Arrow's Most Authentic Pizza

Superior Taste and Quality

By using high-quality ingredients and traditional cooking methods, Old World Pizza ensures that every bite delivers a burst of mouthwatering flavors and exceptional pizza quality.

Personalized Customization

Old World Pizza understands that everyone has different tastes and preferences. With our extensive selection of toppings and crust options, customers can customize their pizzas exactly the way they like, ensuring a personalized and enjoyable dining experience.

Reliable and Timely Delivery

Old World Pizza's reliable delivery services ensure that customers receive their orders promptly and in perfect condition. With efficient delivery practices and real-time updates on order status and delivery time, customers can count on a seamless and satisfying pizza delivery experience.

Highly Reviewed and Locally Owned

Our Passion for Pizza

At Old World Pizza, our love for pizza shines through in every slice we serve, as we are dedicated to creating the perfect combination of flavors and textures that will leave you craving more.

Quality Ingredients

We believe that the key to a truly delicious pizza lies in the quality of the ingredients used. That's why we source only the freshest and finest ingredients, ensuring that each bite is bursting with flavor.

Time-Honored Recipes

With a commitment to preserving the traditions of old-world pizza making, we use time-honored recipes passed down through generations .

Exceptional Customer Service

At Old World Pizza, we strive to provide exceptional customer service, making every visit to our restaurant a memorable one. From friendly and attentive staff to prompt pizza delivery.

Testimonials

Old World Pizza

4.7

Based on 257 reviews

review us on

Lindsay Brixey

19:33 23 Feb 25

Chad Tinney

16:08 23 Feb 25

Great family atmosphere accompanied by a great staff. This is our second time and it was a delicious as the first. This in our opinion had to be the best pizza we've had in Oklahoma. My wife says it's the best calzone she's had and my son loves the chicken bacon ranch pizza. I had the ultimate meat lovers for the second time and it doesn't disappoint. Large amount of toppings and the chocolate cake is incredible. Well worth our 25 minute drive.

Emma Fields

00:20 17 Feb 25

I absolutely love this place! I have never been disappointed. Their homemade ranch is amazing and doesn’t have that vinegar taste! I love their pepperoni pizza and a 10” is a good size if you are wanting to have a personal pizza and possible leftovers. I have never had bad service nor have I ever had bad food here. Highly recommend if you are in the mood for some local pizza!

Morkis

11:15 16 Feb 25

Best pizza ive ever had. Haven't tried much besides the pepperoni pizza, margarita and the cheesy bread. I'm guessing the pasta is just as good. Would recommend everyone come here. YOUR EXPECTATIONS WILL BE EXCEEDED!

SoonerSublime

23:09 13 Feb 25

Near miss in my book. Crust is phenomenal. IMO too much cheese and sauce. The undercarriage is fantastic and it would be a dang near 9.0 or better if it were. My wife loves it but as a connoisseur I have to say it’s a 6.8. I will order again with light cheese and sauce and I bet it’s an 8.3-9.1 I’ll edit my review after round 2.

Cristina Aguirre

01:25 09 Jan 25

We visited for dine in few weeks ago. We ordered a calzone to share my husband and I. To add meats is $2 per each meat. They do not have a kids menu so we ordered spaghetti and small cheese pizza for my kids. They foods was very tasty and our server was attentive. The owner came to check on us. We are coming back next time we want pizza.

bowmee

20:57 04 Jan 25

First time trying pizza from OWP, and I was impressed! Plenty of toppings, good size, and decent cost for what you get. The taste was great! I’ll be back! Yes, I did eat half of the pizza. 🙂

Robert Swain

17:17 18 Nov 24

Wife and dropped in looking for another different pizza place to add to our list. Service was great and food.came out fairly quick. We had cheese bread and meat lovers pizza. We both liked the cheese bread, and the wife was indifferent about pizza, but I liked it. We will be back to try other items.

Daniel Webster

19:57 25 Feb 24

Easily best pizza in town. Such friendly people too.

Chris Marrs

00:19 25 Feb 24

It ok

Jedediah Beloncik

00:18 25 Feb 24

Old World Pizza is the best pizza in BA hands down! Owners are super sweet! Got the pepperoni, chicken, and bacon pizza; and it was incredible! Prices are very fair for a made from scratch pizzeria! 💙

Tom Stewart

02:19 24 Feb 24

Second time to visit. So glad to see the dining area full this evening. Great Pizza. Polite, courteous service and very efficient for the crowd.

Michelle Buford

14:59 18 Feb 24

David Lundy

00:36 18 Feb 24

Amazing food and service. Have never had a bad meal. The owner is the kindest person and very accommodating. We like to eat dairy free and they can make their veggie pizza like that without it being soggy. Hands down my favorite pizza in the area. Give them a shot and support local businesses like this who prioritize their customers and do things the right way.

Local Guide

04:13 27 Dec 23

More businesses need to strive to be this good. Always an excellent product and always accurate. I have no eaten inside the restaurant yet, but definitely roomy from what I’ve seen. The owner/manager always hands me my food and checks to make sure everything is there. Not to mention, tells me how much they appreciate my business and that I enjoy the product. These gestures alone ensure I will keep coming back, thank you!

Justice

13:09 04 Nov 23

Don't order out much but when we do we usually just do dominoes due to being a "cheaper" option when feeding a family of six..but this place here has changed my mind, not only was it affordable but I ordered what everyone had a taste for (picky family). i ended up with 3 small pizzas (1 cheese, 1 pepperoni and 1 spinach) 1 large with 3 toppings (all meats) as well as an order of chicken wings which we're rather spicy but delicious 😋 you can tell they use a brick oven on their pizzas which makes it extra special. Paid just a lil more than I do at other places but most definitely worth it. Will order again

Jerry Shannon

23:54 03 Nov 23

We just had the best pizza I have ever had. It's hard to say what made it so good. Everything was great. I doubt you could get any better pizza anywhere in the world.

Shawna Vessey

18:01 02 Nov 23

Absolutely wonderful! The food was fantastic, the service was even better! We'll be making this our new pizza place!

Robert Neal

04:21 30 Oct 23

My first time trying Old World Pizza, BA, Great pizza, great people! Family business! The place was very clean and warm, the staff amazing! I had a great experience today with my family and friends. The pizza, garlic knots and wings are delicious! The owner was going at the table checking the customers, thank you for the experience.

Jose Alfonso

23:27 20 Oct 23

UPDATE. Again, Standing ovation to this pizza place!. Thank you Lyly and team. The nice and humble way you treat customers talks volume of what is in your hearts. You always make us feel like family. Now, what about the food?. As pizza freaks ourselves this place is great.Beside the pizzas the pasta is way too good. Fresh ingredients!. How come we didn't knew about this restaurant before?. Fresh ingredients. Dough and sauce done in house. Brick pizza oven. Cannoli and their chocolate gelato are a most. Service is A+. Make you feel good. If you live in Broken Arrow, Tulsa or just passing by this place is worth giving a try.

Mia Navarro

01:47 05 Oct 23

Old World Pizza, 732 W New Orleans St Suite 120, Broken Arrow, OK 74011Went with the family to try this brick oven pizzeria, and it did not disappoint. Customer service was on point, as soon as we entered the door we were greeted and then seated, menus brought to the table with silverware in cloth napkings presented and drink & starter order taken (we got the large garlic knots... HIHGLY recommended). We revised the menu and decided to get the Ultimate Meat Lovers and a small cheese pizza and large garlick knots to go. Minutes later, our 5 drinks and garlic knots in an awesome & delicious buttery-garlicky-cheesy sauce with 2 sides of fresh homemade marinara sauce were placed on the table making it a great start and an excellent 1st impression. Minutes later, the master piece arrived, and we digged into that pie with high expectations. The crust was perfect, with those delicate air bubbles on top, the perfect amount of fresh homemade sauce, cheese, and meats perfectly combined, pipping hot and crispy. Now that we have tried it, we are definitely returning because I am curious about their calzone and because we had an amazing experience. Everything we had was $87 & some change.PS. I forgot to take a picture of the small cheese pizza!

Miriam Miller

17:04 13 Aug 23

Very friendly staff. We received a warm welcome when we entered. Server was very sweet and polite. She gave us plenty of time to figure out what we wanted. Answered our questions and was knowledgeable about the food she was serving. Restaurant was clean. Bathrooms were clean.The Pizza was amazing In presentation and in taste. My husband and I orders a half 4 cheese pizza and half meat lovers.It’s a nice fire cooked thin crust Pizza. seemed very authentic to us.We took half the pizza home to eat as a leftover and it was very good warmed up.Even though it’s a good drive for us to get to the pizza place we are going to make this our new got to for pizza. For us it’s worth the drive.I recommend you give this place at least a one stop try to judge for yourself. I don’t think it it will surprise you.

brian chitty

15:17 03 Feb 23

Had to take the time to review this amazing pizza restaurant! This pizza is super unique and delicious. The crust is were its at. Reminded me of similar crusts I've enjoyed in New York. We had the supreme and meat lovers pizza along with the " folded bread" appetizer. Couldn't stop indulging myself ha ha. In addition, the customer service was top notch. You can tell the owner takes pride in their pizza shop. Try this place, you won't be disappointed!